top of page

Break Room Conversations

So much of our formation as healthcare professionals comes through informal conversations with colleagues. Whether we’re based in a hospital or in the community, the opportunity to debrief after a tricky case or to hear how a colleague tackled a workplace situation similar to one we’re facing can prove invaluable. ​We would love to see many conversations happening in staff ‘Break Rooms’ around the UK about the opportunities and challenges facing clinicians who want to practise in ways that honour both the lives of mothers and their unborn babies – but it isn’t always easy to find those conversations.  

 

That’s where Break Room Conversations comes in. Here you’ll find questions that other healthcare professionals have wanted to ask, with answers and reflections from experienced colleagues who share our commitment to healthcare for both lives.  

 

And if your question isn’t here, or you’d value a longer conversation about something similar, send us your question. You might be wondering how others approach a particular clinical situation, navigate a workplace conversation, or think through an ethical question. A good conversation might just give you somewhere to start, or help you take the next step as you think it through. Where it would be helpful, we can connect you with a colleague within Healthcare for Both Lives for an informal conversation over Zoom.  

Question from a thoughtful friend:


A friend recently had an ectopic pregnancy.  I work in healthcare but it’s not something I would see in my work, and I’ve now realised this isn’t something I’ve really thought through ethically.  Where might I start? 

Answer from a GP:  


Managing an ectopic pregnancy can initially seem ethically complicated if you already believe that both the life of the mother and the life of her unborn baby should be protected where possible.  


In an ectopic pregnancy, the embryo has implanted somewhere outside the uterus, most commonly in a fallopian tube. Sadly, there is currently no way of moving that pregnancy into the uterus where the baby could continue to develop. Left untreated, an ectopic pregnancy can rupture and cause life-threatening internal bleeding for the mother. 


So, this is a very different situation to an elective abortion, and it isn’t the same treatment that is offered. Tragically, in an ectopic pregnancy there is no available treatment that can save the baby’s life, the treatment is being offered to care for the mother in a situation in which her baby already cannot survive. 


This distinction helped me when I first thought about this - being committed to healthcare for both lives doesn’t mean that both lives can always be saved. Sometimes we just don’t have treatments that make that possible.  


There are several groups around the world a bit like Healthcare for Both Lives including one in America specifically for Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (AAPLOG) – they have produced a fact sheet about ectopic pregnancy which goes into more detail about the treatments offered.  Theirs might be another perspective worth reflecting on as you consider this topic further.


This answer was written by a signatory of the Healthcare for Both Lives Declaration. We hope it proves a helpful perspective and encourages further conversations. It does not necessarily represent the views of Healthcare for Both Lives or all other declaration signatories. 

Question from a Resident Doctor


I have a placement in Obstetrics and Gynaecology coming up.  I’m nervous that things I’m uncomfortable with might be expected as part of the role (e.g. taking part in offering abortion services). How have others managed this? 

Answer from a GP who worked in O&G during postgraduate training: 


It’s a while ago (I’m now a GP!) but I am glad I spent some time working in O+G during my training.  I learnt a lot and enjoyed the work contributing to the care being offered to women.   


It’s understandable to feel nervous about this, particularly when you’re approaching working in O+G for the first time.  I hope it’s reassuring to hear that I had no significant problems during my placement.   


Before starting your placement, it would be good to try and be clear what you aren’t comfortable being involved with, and to remind yourself of the law and guidance around conscience – perhaps by reading over this article on the Healthcare for Both Lives website.   


From my experience, though, there is no need to go into the placement assuming that there will be conflict or difficulties. Like any placement you’ll want to focus on getting to know your colleagues, being ready to learn and contribute to the many areas of O&G that you’ll want to be fully involved with.  


It will be worth having a conversation with your educational or clinical supervisor early on if you think the placement may include things you’re not comfortable with. You can explain positively that there is lots you are looking forward to learning and doing, while being straightforwardly clear about the areas in which you have a conscientious objection. 


You definitely aren’t the first doctor to have navigated this. If you’d find it helpful to talk through your concerns with someone who has faced similar questions, get in touch and we’ll see if we can connect you with a colleague within Healthcare for Both Lives for a conversation.


This answer was written by a signatory of the Healthcare for Both Lives Declaration. We hope it proves a helpful perspective and encourages further conversations. It does not necessarily represent the views of Healthcare for Both Lives or all other declaration signatories. 

Thanks for submitting a question!

bottom of page